Design Critique Framework

Provide a structured design critique of [DESCRIBE OR LINK THE DESIGN].

Design type: [WEB PAGE / APP SCREEN / LOGO / POSTER / DASHBOARD / EMAIL]
Brand context: [DESCRIBE]

Target user: [WHO]

Evaluate using these lenses:
1. **First Impression** (2 seconds): What does the eye see first? Is it the right thing?
2. **Visual Hierarchy**: Does importance match prominence? Squint test results
3. **Typography**: Readability, scale, pairing, line length, spacing
4. **Color**: Harmony, contrast ratios, emotional association, accessibility
5. **Layout & Spacing**: Alignment, grid consistency, white space, breathing room
6. **Consistency**: Patterns, components, spacing rhythms, interaction patterns
7. **Usability**: Can users accomplish their goal? Where's the friction?
8. **Emotional Response**: How does this design make someone feel?

For each point: What works, what doesn't, and a specific improvement with reasoning.

Provide a structured design critique of [DESCRIBE OR LINK THE DESIGN].

Design type: [WEB PAGE / APP SCREEN / LOGO / POSTER / DASHBOARD / EMAIL]
Brand context: [DESCRIBE]
Target user: [WHO]

Evaluate using these lenses:
1. **First Impression** (2 seconds): What does the eye see first? Is it the right thing?
2. **Visual Hierarchy**: Does importance match prominence? Squint test results
3. **Typography**: Readability, scale, pairing, line length, spacing
4. **Color**: Harmony, contrast ratios, emotional association, accessibility
5. **Layout & Spacing**: Alignment, grid consistency, white space, breathing room
6. **Consistency**: Patterns, components, spacing rhythms, interaction patterns
7. **Usability**: Can users accomplish their goal? Where's the friction?
8. **Emotional Response**: How does this design make someone feel?

For each point: What works, what doesn't, and a specific improvement with reasoning.